Bonefish Bay Motel
12565 Overseas Highway
View on map and nearby hotels
Why people book this hotel
“We had the room before check-in time, just spent time at the pool waiting the ro…”
“Our room had recently been refurbished which was a nice surprise”
“It's quiet, peaceful and in a lovely location”
“Wonderful location”
“;) Clean, comfortable, quite stable Internet connection”
“Great location, helpful friendly staff, big clean rooms, lovely swimming pool, f…”
“Staff (humans and dog ;)) was really friendly and helpful”
“Staff very friendly and willing to help and advise”
“Free kayaks and bicycles, swimming pool and picklebal”
“Pool, shoreline fishing, kayaks, bqq spots”
“Nice place and reasonable price compared to Key West prices”
“Great price compared to others Keys”
Overview
Featuring free WiFi throughout the property, a sun terrace with a swimming pool and a garden, Bonefish Bay Motel is situated in Marathon. The property is around 2.4 km from Sunset Park Beach, 46 km from Upper Matecumbe Key and 17 km from Seven Mile Bridge. Rooms include a balcony with garden views. The rooms at the motel are fitted with a flat-screen TV and a kitchenette. Rooms have a private bathroom with a shower, free toiletries and a hairdryer. At Bonefish Bay Motel each room has bed linen and towels. Popular points of interest near the accommodation include Florida Keys Aquarium Encounters, A Deep Blue Dive Center and Captain Hook s Marina Dive Center. The nearest airport is Key West International Airport, 82 km from Bonefish Bay Motel.
Traveller reviews
Michelle
family_with_children
March 7, 2026
“Great place to stay”
Absolutely love this place. It's quiet, peaceful and in a lovely location. Second time we have stayed. From the UK and we will be back! Love sitting by the water jn the early morning or evening
Amy
family_with_children
January 23, 2026
Wonderful location
Juhani
couple
December 26, 2025
“Value for money when visiting Key West”
Nice place and reasonable price compared to Key West prices. Around 1 hour drive from Key West. Easy drive. Apartment was great, everything we needed. We had the room before check-in time, just spent time at the pool waiting the room to be ready. Thanks again!
Caterina
couple
December 14, 2025
“DO NOT BOOK THIS HOTEL”
DO NOT BOOK THIS HOTEL A truly forgettable experience. The apartment was full of cockroaches (photos attached). We reported the issue to the reception, but nothing was done. When we returned later that evening, the apartment was still infested. We were forced to leave and find another place to stay. The owner repeatedly reassured us that we would receive a refund; nevertheless, the property has continued not to respond either to us or to Booking's customer support. If you want some advice: book elsewhere. The cost was excessive anyway, and the service was awful.
MickeyB
couple
November 19, 2025
“Little gem to relax on the Keys”
The motel is in a good location with a lovely area by the dock to sit and bbq/eat. Our room had recently been refurbished which was a nice surprise.
JOHN
solo_traveller
October 21, 2025
“Living the Tiki Beach Life”
Beach life and kind people
Daria
couple
October 14, 2025
“I would love to be back some day”
Great motel! It exceeded my expectations by miles. ;) Clean, comfortable, quite stable Internet connection. We arrived late and there were no issues with the check-in. They also allowed us to stay after we checked out and take a shower before our flight. Thank you so much for that! Staff (humans and dog ;)) was really friendly and helpful. They even have a pickleball court to play.
Sarah
couple
September 29, 2025
“Excellent value for money”
Great location, helpful friendly staff, big clean rooms, lovely swimming pool, free parking.
Faetsa
family_with_children
July 6, 2025
Ladybat reception was great, the room was big enough and clean. Free kayaks and bicycles, swimming pool and picklebal.
Paul
couple
June 30, 2025
“We would happily stay there again and would recommend it to others”
The location was ideal for what we wanted
LINDA
family_with_children
June 7, 2025
“Great place to stop off on our way to key west”
We weren’t aware of any breakfast available
Crozier
couple
May 22, 2025
The location and the outside
MamaG
couple
May 21, 2025
“Fab location when visiting Florida Keys”
Location was great a good central location when visiting the keys. Great opportunity to use the BBQ one evening. Walking distance to super bar and restaurant “island fish company ‘ .
Marie
couple
May 18, 2025
“Fabulous place with different types of accommodation and all well maintained and very clean, great value for money and i”
Great location with plenty of free activities to keep you occupied on site, rooms very clean spacious and well stocked, we enjoyed and made use of the bbq areas which was always very clean and good quality bbq tools to hand. Staff very friendly and willing to help and advise.
Dirk
family_with_children
April 27, 2025
“Short stay in the Keys”
Everything fine. Late arrival was no problem at all. Stuff was very friendly and helpful. Coffee machine in the room didn’t work, so they replaced it within 10 minutes. Great service
Ken
couple
April 18, 2025
“Highly recommended. Won’t dissapoint.”
Highly recommended. Clean, tidy, well equiped room and facility. Great price compared to others Keys.
Tímea
family_with_children
April 17, 2025
“Spotless motel”
Very clean, well equipped room. The area is beautiful with the lagoon.
Rita
family_with_children
April 13, 2025
“Perfect for our requirements.”
The room was clean and pleasant. Friendly and helpful staff. We were able to use the kayaks free of charge and had a lovely hour or so paddling around the mangroves. Sparky's Landing Restaurant just a short walk away was a fun place to eat, it had a nice keys vibe.
Peter
extended_group
April 6, 2025
“Underrated place in a beautiful area of the Keys”
Was very undersold and had more facilities than we excepted. Pool, shoreline fishing, kayaks, bqq spots. The bathroom was a bit run down and there were some roaches visible at night, for us was not a major issue. Great stay overall, just focus on cleanliness would make it perfect.
Joanne
couple
March 14, 2025
“Great stay at bonefish bay”
Great welcome, Lovely big clean room comfortable bed free parking, walking distance to two lovely bars, free coffee and cake in the morning we didn’t find out this until we were just about to leave though, big clean pool
Facilities
Activities
Fishing, Diving, Snorkelling, Canoeing
Cleanliness & disinfecting
Use of cleaning chemicals that are effective against Coronavirus, Linens, towels and laundry washed in accordance with local authority guidelines, Guest accommodation is disinfected between stays, Guests have the option to cancel any cleaning services for their accommodation during their stay
Food & Drink
Breakfast options
Food & drink safety
All plates, cutlery, glasses and other tableware have been sanitized
General
Air conditioning, WiFi available in all areas, Pets allowed, Non-smoking rooms
Internet
Internet services, Free WiFi, WiFi
Outdoors
Outdoor pool, Garden, Outdoor furniture, Sun terrace, Outdoor pool (all year), Picnic area
Parking
Parking, Free parking, Parking on site
Physical distancing
Cashless payment available, Physical distancing rules followed
Pool and wellness
Swimming pool, Swimming Pool, Fence around pool, Sun loungers or beach chairs
Safety & security
Carbon monoxide detector, Carbon monoxide sources, Key access, Security alarm, Smoke alarms, CCTV outside property, Fire extinguishers
Safety features
Staff follow all safety protocols as directed by local authorities, Hand sanitizer in guest accommodation and key areas, First aid kit available, Access to health care professionals, Face masks for guests available
Self check-in
Lockbox key collection at the property
Services
Private check-in/check-out, Daily housekeeping, Grocery deliveries, Fax/photocopying, Express check-in/check-out, Laundry
Deluxe Double Room (2 Adults + 1 Child)
Guests will find a refrigerator, kitchenware, a microwave and a tea and coffee maker in the well-equipped kitchenette. The double room also comes with a barbecue. The spacious double room features air conditioning, a private entrance, a balcony with garden views as well as a private bathroom boasting a walk-in shower. The unit has 2 beds.
Deluxe King Suite
Boasting a private entrance, this air-conditioned suite includes 1 living room, 1 separate bedroom and 1 bathroom with a walk-in shower and a bath. Guests will find a refrigerator, kitchenware and a microwave in the kitchenette. The suite also features a barbecue. Featuring a balcony with garden views, this suite also offers a tea and coffee maker and a flat-screen TV with streaming services. The unit has 1 bed.
Hotel Policies
Price Watch
Email me price updates for Hotel Bonefish Bay Motel
Each day we'll check prices and send you an email for your selected dates at Bonefish Bay Motel.
If you don't have specific dates but would like to check prices for say next weekend or say next month we can check the price too.