Hotel on the Cay
PO Box 223329
View on map and nearby hotels
Why people book this hotel
“Beautiful location”
“Location”
“Staff was very friendly and accommodating”
“The staff was extremely friendly, accommodating, welcoming, helpful, supportive …”
“Rooms badly needs up dating and deep cleaning”
“No breakfast option”
“It is out dated and needs painting and the pool is not working but over all all …”
Overview
Located on lush Protestant Cay and accessible only by boat, this Christiansted landmark hotel features a private beach. Free WiFi is available in all areas. A private balcony, a kitchenette and cable TV are found in each bright, decorative room at Hotel on the Cay. Coffee-making facilities and a DVD player are also included. Guests of the Cay Hotel can go snorkelling or enjoy tours by wave runner or kayak. Windsurfing, sailing and paddle boat rentals are also available. An on-site bar and a restaurant are open to all guests of the cay. Central Christiansted is a 2-minute ferry ride from the hotel. The Buccaneer Golf Club is less than 5 km away.
Traveller reviews
Maija
solo_traveller
June 10, 2025
“Relaxing stay with a basic room”
Beautiful location
Colin P
solo_traveller
January 18, 2025
“Unexceptable”
The cay is nice.
ISLAND
solo_traveller
December 15, 2024
“Good with a lack of staff”
Location
angel
solo_traveller
May 14, 2024
It's a good spot, need an update every where ! Please do it! It's a beatiful place
Iyoka
solo_traveller
April 6, 2024
The location
ALICIA
extended_group
February 29, 2024
“Perfect place to stay if you love the beach!”
This location was great for us! Staff was very friendly and accommodating. We loved the beach access a few steps away from the hotel. The boat people who took us to Christiansted were always friendly and on point. Overall great experience.
Julia
family_with_children
February 25, 2024
“Nice!”
I liked the fact that it was on the beach - literally! The staff was extremely friendly, accommodating, welcoming, helpful, supportive and engaging.
John
solo_traveller
January 31, 2024
I realize that the new owners want to fix this place up - but it really had the feeling of a condemned building. Cracked floor tiles, sagging mattresses, flecks of food in the sink. Dreary.
utterbl
extended_group
January 28, 2024
“Stay was great minus the lack of pool that is advertised.”
This is a very laid back place. It is out dated and needs painting and the pool is not working but over all all of the guests and staff were very friendly. Great Vaca.
David
extended_group
September 15, 2023
“A great value hotel in the best location.”
No breakfast option.
Hazlan
extended_group
June 1, 2022
“Good”
Rooms badly needs up dating and deep cleaning.
Karmon
extended_group
May 11, 2022
“LOVE LOVE LOVE you all!!!!!”
The Water Taxi Captains were amazing! Hats off to Noel, Miles and Roger who made our trip excellent! The hospitality from EVERYONE was AMAZING! We all highly recommend Hotel on the Cay!
Widener
solo_traveller
February 23, 2022
“I love the location, the staff, the views..”
Everything except no food service Will stay again
Malcolm
solo_traveller
January 30, 2022
“my stay here was ok”
John
extended_group
October 21, 2021
“Need more activities like they used to”
Beech
Patricia
couple
May 24, 2021
The place was filthy
Facilities
Activities
Fishing, Hiking, Diving, Private beach area, Beachfront, Beach
Food & Drink
Breakfast options, Bar
General
Family rooms, Non-smoking rooms, WiFi available in all areas, Safety deposit box, Air conditioning
Internet
Internet services, WiFi, Free WiFi
Outdoors
BBQ facilities, Garden, Terrace, Sun terrace
Parking
Parking, Free parking
Services
Fax/photocopying, Meeting/banquet facilities, 24-hour front desk, Laundry, Vending machine (drinks)
Two-Bedroom Apartment
This spacious apartment comes with 1 living room, 2 separate bedrooms and 1 bathroom with a shower and free toiletries. Guests can make meals in the kitchenette that features a refrigerator, kitchenware, a microwave and a toaster. This apartment has air conditioning, a tea and coffee maker, a flat-screen TV with satellite channels and a terrace. The unit has 2 beds.
Double Room with Balcony (2 Adults + 1 Child)
The unit offers 1 bed.
Superior Ocean View Double Queen
In the fully equipped kitchenette, guests will find a refrigerator, kitchenware, a microwave and a tea and coffee maker. This air-conditioned double room is comprised of a flat-screen TV with satellite channels, a private bathroom as well as a terrace. The unit has 2 beds.
Superior Ocean View King
Guests can make meals in the kitchenette that features a refrigerator, kitchenware, a microwave and a tea and coffee maker. This air-conditioned double room is comprised of a flat-screen TV with satellite channels, a private bathroom as well as a terrace. The unit has 1 bed.
Queen Room with Two Queen Beds
The unit has 2 beds.
Family Suite
This spacious suite comes with 1 living room, 2 separate bedrooms and 1 bathroom with a shower and free toiletries. In the fully equipped kitchenette, guests will find a refrigerator, kitchenware, a microwave and a toaster. Boasting a terrace, this suite also features air conditioning, a tea and coffee maker and a flat-screen TV with satellite channels. The unit has 3 beds.
King Suite with Balcony
The unit has 2 beds.
Hotel Policies
Price Watch
Email me price updates for Hotel Hotel on the Cay
Each day we'll check prices and send you an email for your selected dates at Hotel on the Cay.
If you don't have specific dates but would like to check prices for say next weekend or say next month we can check the price too.