“New England as in a dream”

Staying at the Edgartown Inn is like walking into the pages of a refined New England design magazine — but with soul, warmth, and genuine kindness woven into every detail. The interiors are a perfect blend of coastal elegance and curated simplicity, each room bathed in light and beauty. But what truly sets this place apart are the thoughtful touches and extraordinary hospitality. Mornings begin with a divine breakfast: artisan Nada Bread bursting with berries, homemade cranberry juice, creamy coconut chia seed pudding, perfectly cooked eggs — all served with care and generosity. Fresh water, rich coffee, and the unforgettable Championship cookies are always within reach. Beyond the aesthetics and comfort, it’s the team’s sincere attention that makes the experience unforgettable. Whether it’s offering insider tips on the best hidden corners of Martha’s Vineyard, recommending the perfect sunset spot, or simply sharing a smile, there’s a constant sense of care and presence. It’s more than a stay — it’s a heartfelt invitation to feel at home, embraced by beauty and kindness.

“The place to be. No doubt.”

My stay at The Edgartown Inn was nothing short of a magical escape, a dream come true on the enchanting island of Martha’s Vineyard, a place I had longed to discover for years. And it truly lived up to every expectation – and beyond. The Edgartown Inn is the very definition of refined simplicity: elegant without excess, effortlessly tasteful, welcoming yet serene. Perfectly located, it radiates the charm of those coastal interiors you find in the most beautiful design magazines, with that special atmosphere, cosy, curated, and deeply comforting. Everything was just right: the exceptional breakfasts, understated yet incredibly classy; the genuine kindness of the staff – and most especially Neusa, whose grace, care, and professionalism made the experience unforgettable. This is a place that ticks every box: elegance, serenity, balance, and sophistication. A true haven of peace, exactly how you imagine New England at its finest. I recommend it a thousand times over, and I’ll return with my eyes closed.

Great location, lovely breakfast, lovely hotel - very new

Loved everything!

“Great stay in a beautiful hotel in the middle of Edgartown”

Small and intimate hotel in great location; super friendly staff

Location was excellent

“Enjoyable stay and would both recommend and revisit.”

The property was in an excellent location and was extremely welcoming. We arrived early but not a problem at all, we were treated to some warm chocolate cookies just out the oven. A very restful place to stay and everything in Edgartown is within walking distance. Good tips on where to visit and dine.

Location, homey feel

“A good 5 start. Not outstanding”

The room was clean and the location ideal

“Would recommend this inn to anyone going to Martha’s Vineyard”

Excellent value for money and location Breakfast lovely

“Absolutely stunning hotel - great staff”

Absolutely everything !! Could not ask for anything more.

“Wonderful”

Spotlessly clean, central location

We had the most amazing stay at the Edgartown Inn! Great location, few minutes walk to the center of town and the harbor. The property manager is a lovely person, she helped us with activities and restaurants recommendations.

“For the perfect vacation, you need to come here!”

The rooms were perfect - very spacious, light and clean. The property manager was the most lovely, wonderful person any facility could have. She prepared the most amazing breakfasts, offered to launder garments for us, and recommend restaurants for us. That made for a perfect vacation. We would come back in a minute if we could!

“The core of New England spirit”

Location, Decoration and type of building and most of all the proficiency and care of Neusa the real local "Jack of all trades"

“fabulously helpful staff”

Good position in the town good airy clean rooms

“Nice hotel, with spacious, modern and well equipped room and bathroom. Great location and charming outside common areas”

“Nice hotel, with spacious, modern and well equipped room and bathroom. Great location and charming outside common areas”